Dir: James Watkins
Cast: Tom Rhys Harries, Naomi Ackie, David Dencik, Max Minghella, Eddie Marsan, Joshua James, Joana Ribeiro

This effectively grisly body horror breathes new life into the usual comic book offerings, but despite a solid lead performance, clunky dialogue and unconvincing character arcs result in a messy introduction for the DC villain
For years, comic book movies stuck to a tried-and-tested formula, but since Todd Phillips‘ highly controversial character study “Joker” hit screens in 2019, the genre has begun to break free from its conventions. Critics and audiences were split over the film’s bold attempt to elevate the DC villain’s origins, with Phillips tipping his hat to the gritty, character-driven dramas of the 1970s, especially Martin Scorsese’s work. Personally, I was largely won over by this daring new direction for comic book adaptations, and if not for the film’s unprecedented box office success for a mature-rated release, we might never have seen the equally gritty yet more universally adored “The Batman” in 2022.
The rise of these darker comic adaptations has begun to reshape comic book cinema, especially at DC, where new creative head James Gunn is determined to breathe new life into the brand and challenge the struggling Marvel Cinematic Universe for the top spot. After starting his DC Universe with the classic, god-like heroes in “Superman” and “Supergirl”, Gunn—whose roots are in horror—has boldly plunged into body-horror territory for the DCU’s third film, “Clayface”. Originally conceived by Mike Flanagan in 2021, the “Haunting of Hill House” creator pitched a standalone film as a devoted fan of this B-tier Batman villain. For years, rumours swirled about Clayface’s DCU debut, with speculation he might appear in Matt Reeves’ “The Batman: Part II”, but the shapeshifter made his surprise entrance in the animated series “Creature Commandos” in 2024, the first official DCU release.
Though a Clayface film wasn’t originally on the cards, the character’s origins were eventually greenlit as a prequel to “Creature Commandos” after Gunn was captivated by Flanagan’s pitch and draft scripts. However, with Flanagan tied up directing the upcoming “The Exorcist: Martyrs” and the recently released “Carrie” TV series, he had to step aside, paving the way for James Watkins to take the helm. Finally, principal photography kicked off in 2025, four years after Flanagan first voiced his big-screen ambitions.
The end product is a bold, sometimes stomach-turning body horror that not only makes the villain more sympathetic but also sets the stage for his future in the DCU. Before his monstrous transformation, Hollywood star Matt Hagen (Tom Rhys Harries) is the toast of Tinseltown, fresh off his first Academy Award nomination and poised for superstardom. When he returns to Gotham City, Matt joins his childhood friend and fellow actor Corey (Joshua James) at a nightclub, only to make the fateful mistake of spending the night with actress Mia Torrez (Joana Ribeiro), who happens to be the girlfriend of Gotham crime boss Markos Szabo (David Dencik).
The following morning, Szabo and his thugs ambush Matt, brutally disfiguring his face with a knife. Though Matt goes to the police, Szabo’s grip on the city and lack of evidence leave him powerless to seek justice. Szabo then uses his influence to publicly ruin Matt, blacklisting him with false assault allegations and exploiting his new appearance. Desperate, Matt tracks down fringe scientist Caitlyn Corr (Naomi Ackie), who is developing a nanite treatment to heal damaged tissue. Volunteering as her first human subject, Matt is injected with nanites that at first seem to restore his face, but he soon discovers his features melt under stress, he can recover from any injury, and he can morph into others. Armed with these powers, Matt sets out for revenge against Szabo and everyone who destroyed his life.
Like its shape-shifting antihero, “Clayface” is a messy patchwork, with key scenes seemingly left behind in the editing room. The result is a vengeance tale that often feels unconvincing and muddled. After a promising setup and some effective body horror, Flanagan and co-writer Hossein Amini‘s script starts to unravel, tossing out intriguing themes about Hollywood’s harsh beauty standards and the fragility of ego, only to abandon them for a jumbled B-movie tone. I love a good grindhouse romp, but “Clayface” tries to be both a deep character study and a scrappy B-movie horror, and ends up falling short on both fronts. The lack of focus left me questioning the main character’s motivations. Yes, Matt is wronged and stripped of his looks and fame by Gotham’s underworld, but after showing remorse for his first two kills, he suddenly gives in to bloodlust, dispatching his enemies in ever more grotesque ways with barely a second thought.
I also found myself wishing the film delved deeper into Matt’s life before his rise to fame. The story nudges us to sympathise with this future DC villain, yet hints at a troubled past surfacing during court testimonies with Szabo. Maybe these witnesses were bribed by the crime boss, or maybe there’s truth to their claims, possibly linked to Matt’s childhood under an abusive father. This more intriguing character arc is only brushed upon, most noticeably during a late action sequence where Matt briefly morphs into his father—a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it cameo from Aaron Paul. If the film had explored Matt’s dark history more fully, his descent might have felt more compelling and believable. Instead, it feels jarring and disconnected from the sympathetic character we followed in the first two acts.
What truly sets “Clayface” apart is its bold, offbeat tone, especially for a comic book film. While it heavily echoes Sam Raimi‘s “Darkman” (1990) and draws clear inspiration from David Cronenberg, I found it refreshing to see an 18-rated superhero movie on the big screen. The grisly effects deliver some genuinely gruesome deaths, even if the film never quite reaches the shock factor I anticipated. The practical effects on Tom Rhys Harries are outstanding, with some memorably grotesque transformation scenes—one involving scissors in an airplane toilet is particularly squirm-inducing. Yet, the film’s modest $40 million budget shows in the CGI-heavy sequences, where Matt’s more extreme transformations look less convincing. This limited budget also hampers the world-building. Gotham’s streets are suitably grungy, but nothing really marks this as the DCU’s version of the city. Filmed in Liverpool like “The Batman”, the setting here feels oddly sterile and uninspired, making Gotham’s presence almost irrelevant. Perhaps the generic cityscape is meant to leave room for future DCU Batman films, but as a standalone, I expected more attention to detail in the world design.
Harries shines as Hagen, marking a breakout moment for the 36-year-old Welsh actor. While it’s unclear how he’ll fit into the DCU going forward, I hope this role propels him to bigger and better things—unlike his ill-fated on-screen counterpart. Harries brings unexpected nuance to Hagen in the first act, making me wonder if he’s truly a good guy or simply coasting on looks and fame. Even as the script grows more generic and shaky, Harries commands the screen, matched by Ackie, who is reliably excellent. Though I never quite bought into Hagen’s obsessive fixation on Caitlyn, I did believe in their dynamic as scientist and guinea pig. It’s unfortunate that neither actor gets a natural character arc to add real complexity to their roles.
There were aspects of “Clayface” I enjoyed, and on balance I would recommend it to fans of both horror and comic book movies, but overall I was left wanting more gore and body horror, which only truly impresses in fleeting moments. Harries cements himself as a star with his breakout performance, but he’s ultimately let down by a muddled, formulaic script that never quite captures the spirit of 1970s character dramas or the wild energy of classic B-movie body horror.
Clayface is now showing in UK Cinemas

Leave a Reply